“This book is beautifully written. Specialists who already know the broad outlines will be interested in learning the Ohio story, and for nonspecialists, the book will be an engaging introduction to the subject.”

Stuart Banner, author of The Death Penalty: An American History

No Winners Here Tonight is a sophisticated and critical analysis of Ohio’s death penalty system in the post-Furman era. Among the book’s many strengths is its focus on the shortcomings built into Ohio’s death penalty statute that render it unable to deliver fair and impartial justice.”

Northwest Ohio History

“I highly recommend this book to academic law libraries, especially those that support victim’s rights clinics or innocence projects. I also recommend it for prison libraries.”

Law Library Journal

“This book seeks to document that there is nothing new about the ‘capricious, uneven’ way in which the death penalty is meted out. Welsh-Huggins makes this case anecdotally, recalling case-by-case problems that have plagued and continue to plague Ohio’s death penalty system.”


“In his groundbreaking new book, No Winners Here Tonight, Associated Press reporter Andrew Welsh-Huggins examines Ohio’s death penalty from a historical perspective and concludes we’ve been asking the wrong questions. The point, Welsh-Huggins tells us, is not whether capital punishment is moral but if it’s fair…. No Winners Here Tonight (should be) required reading for death penalty opponents and supporters alike.”

The Blade

“Welsh-Huggins…crafts his thesis by combining history and law. While incorporating some “classic” sources on the death penalty—Hugu Adam Bedau, William Brennan, Thurgood Marshall, Austin Sarat—Welsh-Huggins maintains a reporter’s objectivity and pens a clear explanation as to why the current death penalty system in Ohio is unfair. This is a book about how Ohio, in many ways, is no different than the rest of the United States in regards to capital punishment: arbitrary.”

Law & Politics Book Review

“Welsh-Huggins has a journalist’s clear style and the advantage of expanding and detailing only one topic…. A recent poll suggested that seventy percent of Ohioans strongly support the death penalty. It would be interesting to frame that survey around some of the questions raised by Welsh-Huggins in his thought-provoking book.”

Columbus Bar Lawyers Quarterly

“This book is an original and important project that makes significant contribution to the field.”

Douglas A. Berman, William B. Saxbe Designated Professor of Law, Moritz College of Law, Ohio State University

Few subjects are as intensely debated in the United States as the death penalty. Some form of capital punishment has existed in America for hundreds of years, yet the justification for carrying out the ultimate sentence is a continuing source of controversy. No Winners Here Tonight explores the history of the death penalty and the question of its fairness through the experience of a single state, Ohio, which, despite its moderate midwestern values, has long had one of the country’s most active death chambers.

In 1958, just four states accounted for half of the forty-eight executions carried out nationwide, each with six: California, Georgia, Ohio, and Texas. By the first decade of the new century, Ohio was second only to Texas in the number of people put to death each year. No Winners Here Tonight looks at this trend and determines that capital punishment has been carried out in an uneven fashion from its earliest days, with outcomes based not on blind justice but on the color of a person’s skin, the whim of a local prosecutor, or the biases of the jury pool in the county in which a crime was committed.

Andrew Welsh-Huggins’s work is the only comprehensive study of the history of the death penalty in Ohio. His analysis concludes that the current law, crafted by lawmakers to punish the worst of the state’s killers, doesn’t come close to its intended purpose and instead varies widely in its implementation. Welsh-Huggins takes on this controversial topic evenhandedly and with respect for the humanity of the accused and the victim alike. This exploration of the law of capital punishment and its application will appeal to students of criminal justice as well as those with an interest in law and public policy.

Andrew Welsh-Huggins is legal affairs reporter with the Associated Press in Columbus, Ohio. He has written extensively on capital punishment, the drug trade, and politics. He is the author of three Andy Hayes mysteries, Fourth Down Out, Slow Burn, and Capitol Punishment.
Photo credit: Emma Welsh-Huggins

Related Titles

Cover of 'The  History of Ohio Law'
Cover of 'Closing Arguments'
Cover of 'Religion in Ohio'
Cover of 'Separate from the World'